False Hope - False Advertising?
Brett R. Saunders
Description
Collection
Title:
False Hope - False Advertising?
Creator:
Brett R. Saunders
Date:
7/22/2000
Text:
While reading the paper this morning, I found a story which both warmed my
heart and left me feeling bad.
It is about an O&P facility that is fitting a young man from overseas with
bilateral shoulder disarticulation/Intrascapular thoracic body powered
prosthetic devices.
I was troubled by the claims that were made to the press. It is reported
that this young man will be able to surf the internet and be able to lift 30
pound objects with his new arms.
Surfing the internet has been both possible and practicle without the use of
arms for a long time. Voice recognition software is just one solution that
works well at very low cost. And while I may not be an expert on all that
is upper extremity, I feel confident that the number of very high level
upper extremity amputees that can lift 30 pound objects is quite small.
Making claims such as this is like the used car dealer promoting a sale
without making an honest disclosure of the facts. While it may draw
business to your facility, it gives false hope and hurts our profession as a
whole.
Brett R. Saunders, CPO, FAAOP
heart and left me feeling bad.
It is about an O&P facility that is fitting a young man from overseas with
bilateral shoulder disarticulation/Intrascapular thoracic body powered
prosthetic devices.
I was troubled by the claims that were made to the press. It is reported
that this young man will be able to surf the internet and be able to lift 30
pound objects with his new arms.
Surfing the internet has been both possible and practicle without the use of
arms for a long time. Voice recognition software is just one solution that
works well at very low cost. And while I may not be an expert on all that
is upper extremity, I feel confident that the number of very high level
upper extremity amputees that can lift 30 pound objects is quite small.
Making claims such as this is like the used car dealer promoting a sale
without making an honest disclosure of the facts. While it may draw
business to your facility, it gives false hope and hurts our profession as a
whole.
Brett R. Saunders, CPO, FAAOP
Citation
Brett R. Saunders, “False Hope - False Advertising?,” Digital Resource Foundation for Orthotics and Prosthetics, accessed November 27, 2024, https://library.drfop.org/items/show/214551.
